29 St Nicholas Ave – A Detailed Decision Review for Student Tenants
29 St Nicholas Ave is a shared apartment building located in Brooklyn, New York (NY 11237). Operated through the Amber platform, it offers rooms in 4‑bedroom units and standard apartments. The property is aimed at students or young professionals looking for a mid‑price option in New York City. Below is a fact‑based breakdown of what this residence offers, who it works for, and what actual tenants have reported.
Property Overview
- Location: Brooklyn, NY 11237, USA
- Unit types: 4‑bedroom (private room in shared apartment) and full apartments
- Price range: $1,500 – $1,600 per month (indicative — confirm with the operator)
- Minimum lease: 6 months
- Amenities indicated: Laundry facility, bills included, TV
- Current availability status: The property is tagged as “not_available” in the data source – check live availability before applying.
The property sits within a diverse residential area of Brooklyn. While no universities are explicitly linked in the supplied data, the location provides access to parts of New York City via subway and bus. The starting price for student housing across the city is $850 per month (based on aggregated data from 212 properties), meaning 29 St Nicholas Ave is priced above the citywide floor but not at the luxury end.
Who This Residence Suits
Students or renters who value included bills and a full lease term.
The rent covers utilities (bills included), which simplifies monthly budgeting. With a minimum 6‑month lease, it suits those who need a stable home for a full semester or academic year without worrying about short‑term extensions.
Those comfortable with a group living arrangement.
The primary unit type is a 4‑bedroom apartment, meaning you will share common areas (kitchen, living room, bathroom) with up to three other tenants. If you enjoy a social environment and can manage shared living, this setup reduces individual cost.
Tenants who prioritise location ratings and basic amenities.
Internal rating dimensions show very high scores for staff (4.8), social atmosphere (4.8), cleaning (4.8), internet (4.9), location (4.8), and value for money (4.8). While these are not independently verified (see reviews below), they suggest that tenants who rated via the Amber platform were generally satisfied with the service and location. The building offers a laundry facility and TV, which are standard for the price tier.
Who This Residence Does Not Suit
Those requiring a short stay or flexible move‑in.
With a minimum 6‑month lease, this property is not suited for a few weeks or a month. Also, the property is currently listed as not available, so immediate move‑in is not certain – you must confirm with the operator.
Travelers or renters with heavy luggage / mobility concerns.
One Google review (by “R D”, rating 1) explicitly states: “The communication was terrible. We requested a few months before our stay a room on a lower floor due to having several suitcases. We never got any reply, even though we emailed them several times. They put us on the top floor (4th). We had to bring up 6 suitcases for an one night stay. The hotel itself is old and run”. Although the property is marketed as a residence (not a hotel), the building has no elevator, and the fourth floor involves carrying luggage up stairs. If you have physical restrictions or heavy belongings, this may be problematic.
Tenants who expect high cleanliness standards.
Another review (by “HaloHead193”, rating 2) states: “Don’t feel like the bed was cleaned just because i pulled the covers and there was hair and lint left on the bed.” This suggests that housekeeping may be inconsistent. If you require a spotless environment upon arrival, you may want to verify cleaning protocols.
Those who value professional front‑desk or on‑site management.
A third review (by “Gihan Jayatilaka”, rating 1) reports: “Extremely rude front desk person. Still didn’t see the rooms. Will update this about the rooms once I go in (if she is able to find our reservation).” Poor customer service can be a deal‑breaker for those who rely on staff for maintenance or assistance.
Budget‑conscious renters seeking the lowest possible price.
The citywide starting price is $850 per month. 29 St Nicholas Ave costs roughly double that. If you are on a tight budget, cheaper options exist, especially outside prime Brooklyn locations. Conversely, if you need a private room in a shared apartment in a convenient part of Brooklyn, this price is within the middle range.
What Residents Actually Say: Quoted Reviews
The three Google reviews provided are all critical. Because we must quote verbatim and cannot fabricate positive feedback, the picture from independent sources is negative. The internal Amber ratings (staff 4.8, social 4.8, etc.) are very high, which may reflect a different subset of tenants (those who booked via Amber and chose to rate). The contrast is notable.
- R D (rating 1): Criticism about poor communication regarding room assignment and the effort of carrying luggage to the 4th floor. Also mentioned the building is “old”.
- Gihan Jayatilaka (rating 1): Complaint about rude front‑desk staff and inability to find the reservation.
- HaloHead193 (rating 2): Concern about bed cleanliness (hair and lint).
These comments indicate that while the building and pricing may look fine on paper, operational issues (customer service, cleanliness, accessibility) have affected past guests. If you are considering a long‑term lease, you should contact the current operator directly to ask about these concerns and request a room inspection or virtual tour.
Price Positioning vs the City From‑Price
The citywide from‑price for student housing in New York City (based on 212 properties listed on the platform) is $850 per month. 29 St Nicholas Ave is listed at $1,500–$1,600 per month. This places it well above the floor but not at the top of the range (many private studios or luxury buildings exceed $2,500+).
In the Brooklyn area specifically, $1,500–$1,600 for a room in a 4‑bedroom apartment with bills included is a common price point. You can find cheaper rooms (around $1,000–$1,200) in less central neighborhoods like Bushwick or East New York, but 29 St Nicholas Ave is in the Ridgewood / Bushwick border area, which has seen rising rents. The bills‑included feature adds value — without it, utilities can add $100–$200 per month.
Key takeaway: The price is moderate for Brooklyn. Confirm with the operator whether the $1,500–$1,600 covers all utilities (electricity, water, gas, internet) and any additional fees (security deposit, cleaning fee). The data shows no deposit amount, so ask upfront.
Room‑Type Guidance
- 4‑bedroom apartment: You get a private bedroom and share the living room, kitchen, and bathroom(s) with three other tenants. This is the most cost‑effective option. Expect common areas to be shared and noise from housemates. The minimum lease of 6 months works well for a semester or a year.
- Full apartment: If the unit type “apartment” means a studio or one‑bedroom, the price would likely be similar to or higher than the shared room – but the data does not break down pricing per unit type. Contact the operator to clarify which price corresponds to which unit.
Tagged amenities include laundry facility (likely shared), bills included, and TV. Note that the property is marked “not_available” in the current dataset, so you must verify that the unit you want is open for bookings.
Booking Timing
The property is currently listed as not available. The “available_from” field is null. If you are planning for 2026 or 2027, you should start inquiries at least 3–4 months before your intended move‑in date. New York City student housing often gets reserved early (January–March for September move‑ins). However, because this building may have intermittent availability, checking the platform regularly or contacting the operator directly is essential.
Given the negative reviews, it is also wise to request a video tour or, if you are already in New York, visit the building in person. You can ask the operator about the specific room you would get (floor level, condition of furniture, recent cleaning) and whether previous complaints have been addressed.
Frequently Asked Questions
H3: Is the price really $1,500–$1,600 per month, and does it include all bills?
The listed price range is $1,500–$1,600 monthly (indicative — confirm with the operator). The property has a “bills_included” tag, which typically covers water, electricity, gas, and internet. However, there may be additional fees (e.g., security deposit, cleaning fee, or late payment charges). You should get a written breakdown before signing any agreement.
H3: How can I verify the cleanliness and condition of the room before booking?
Based on a resident’s comment about a “bed… not cleaned”, you should request photos or a live video tour of the specific unit you will occupy. Ask about the cleaning schedule (is there a weekly cleaner? do tenants clean themselves?). Check the Google rating (3.9 from 349 reviews) and read other reviews on Google Maps or the platform to see if cleanliness issues are common or isolated.
H3: Can I book for less than the minimum 6‑month lease?
The data shows a minimum lease of 6 months. No shorter durations are indicated. If you only need a room for a couple of months, this property is not suitable. You may look for other residences in New York City that offer short‑term options (month‑to‑month or 3‑month leases), though they often come at a premium.
Sources & data date: 2026-07
All pricing, availability, and reviews are based on data collected as of July 2026. Prices are indicative – confirm with the operator before committing.
For live availability and current pricing, use the on‑site assistant on the Amber platform.
See also: listing details · browse more